My Sugar Pie

Pick your pie. Pour your BREW. Enjoy the BOO! My Sugar Pie is joining the Boos & Brews fun! Stop in for a slice of their delicious handmade pie, pair it with a freshly BREWed cup of coffee and enjoy the perfect fall treat.

My Sugar Pie has been a staple of Zionsville for over almost 20 years with a wide variety of pies, all handmade, with a light, crispy crust from owner Kelly Maucere’s mother’s original recipe. This is a must stop for a whole pie or a little slice of heaven! They offer cream, fruit, and fun favorites for every pie lover. And they ship their pies nationwide.

Grab a slice, sip a BREW and enjoy a little taste of fall in Boo-ne County!

40 E Pine St
Zionsville, IN 46077

317-733-8717